| Position | First | Second | Third | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WR | Mike Evans | Justin Watson | Tyler Johnson | |
| TE | Rob Gronkowski | Cameron Brate | ||
| LT | Donovan Smith | Josh Wells | ||
| LG | Ali Marpet | Aaron Stinnie | ||
| C | Ryan Jensen | A.Q. Shipley | ||
| RG | Alex Cappa | |||
| RT | Tristan Wirfs | Joe Haeg | ||
| TE | O.J. Howard | |||
| WR | Chris Godwin | Scotty Miller | Jaydon Mickens | |
| QB | Tom Brady | Blaine Gabbert | Ryan Griffin | |
| RB | Ronald Jones II | LeSean McCoy | Leonard Fournette | Ke'Shawn Vaughn |
| Position | First | Second | Third | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DE | Ndamukong Suh | Khalil Davis | ||
| NT | Vita Vea | Rakeem Nunez-Roches | ||
| DE | William Gholston | Patrick O'Connor | ||
| OLB | Jason Pierre-Paul | Anthony Nelson | ||
| ILB | Devin White | Kevin Minter | ||
| ILB | Lavonte David | Jack Cichy | ||
| OLB | Shaquil Barrett | Quinton Bell | Cam Gill | |
| CB | Carlton Davis | Ryan Smith | Parnell Motley | |
| CB | Sean Murphy-Bunting | Jamel Dean | ||
| S | Antoine Winfield Jr. | Mike Edwards | ||
| S | Jordan Whitehead | Andrew Adams |
| Position | First | Second | Third | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P | Bradley Pinion | |||
| PK | Ryan Succop | |||
| KO | Bradley Pinion | |||
| H | Bradley Pinion | |||
| LS | Zach Triner | |||
| PR | Jaydon Mickens | Scotty Miller | Sean Murphy-Bunting | Antoine Winfield Jr. |
| KR | Jaydon Mickens | Antoine Winfield Jr. |