Skip to main content
Advertising

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Top Five Passing Performances in Bucs History | 50 Seasons

Craig Erickson had the first “perfect game” in franchise history, Baker Mayfield made history at Lambeau and Tom Brady had a whole game in a single half…Do those games make the list of the best passing performances by a Buccaneer?

bestqb

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers will play their 50th season in 2025, extending a rich history that includes two Super Bowl championships, multiple figures inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame and countless moments that live on forever in the memory of Buccaneers fans. While the 50th season gives the Buccaneers organization and its fans an opportunity to celebrate all of its significant achievements of the past, it is also an optimistic look forward at what is yet to come for the NFL's 27th franchise.

As the Buccaneers continue to chase championships and set new team records, it will find that the bar has been set very high in many categories. As we prepare for the arrival of Tampa Bay's 50th season, we will be looking at some of the most impressive team and individual achievements over the first 49 years. Today, we remember the best passing games ever produced by Buccaneer quarterbacks.

This one required a little definition, because there are multiple ways to rank a single-game passing performance. For instance, there have been four instances of a Tampa Bay quarterback throwing for more than 450 yards in a game; are those the top four performances? It's worth noting that two of those four outings came in Buccaneer losses. How about touchdown passes? Six different Bucs quarterbacks have produced five-TD games a total of eight times, including three by Tom Brady and one by Baker Mayfield. But that's a tough tie to break when trying to turn eight games into a top-five list. Passer rating is more of an all-inclusive stat, but a little bit flawed.

In the end, we went with passer rating as the starting point, eliminated any outings that came in a loss and then used yards and touchdowns as a tiebreaker to rank the top five. We also chose to include only one performance from each quarterback, or the Bucs' current starter might have shown up two or three times on this list.

View images from the Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Phase 2 Week 3 Workouts on Tuesday, May 20th, 2025.

The Top Five Passing Games in Buccaneers History

1. Baker Mayfield, at Green Bay, Dec. 17, 2023

Passer rating: 158.3

Passing yards: 381

Touchdown passes: 4

There have been three instances of a Tampa Bay passer recording a perfect 158.3 passer rating in a game in which he has thrown at least 10 passes, and all three are represented in this top five. Mayfield gets the top spot because of the added level of difficulty: the 2023 Packers were a prime NFC contender and Lambeau Field in December can be quite a challenge (this game was 36-degree wind chill and wins of 10 miles per hour at kickoff). In fact, Mayfield was the first and remains the only visiting passer ever to record a perfect passer rating at Lambeau Field.

Mayfield was nearly flawless, completing 22 of 28 passes for 381 yards, four touchdowns and no interceptions. He had a completion percentage of 78.6% and picked up 13.6 yards per attempt despite getting sacked five times. In the process, he became just the third player in league history to have a 158.3 passer rating in a road game in which he threw for at least 375 yards and four touchdowns. The other two were Nick Foles in 2013 and Ken O'Brien in 1986. A rare performance indeed!

2. Brad Johnson, vs. Minnesota, Nov. 3, 2002

Passer rating: 148.3

Passing yards: 313

Touchdown passes: 5

This performance jumps ahead of the other two "perfect games" on the list because of the five touchdowns and zero interceptions. Johnson only missed that 158.3 mark because his yards per attempt weren't quite high enough to get the top score (he would have needed 75 more yards to get there), but this was still a hyper-efficient outing. This was the first time in franchise history that a quarterback had thrown five touchdown passes and no interceptions in a single game.

It also doesn't hurt that this came right in the middle of the season in which the Bucs would eventually chase down a first-round bye and a path to their first Super Bowl championship. It also happened against the team that drafted Johnson in the ninth round in 1992 and gave him 23 starts over five seasons. He completed 24 of his 31 passes and had three touchdowns and a comfortable lead by halftime.

3. Tom Brady, at Detroit, Dec. 26, 2020

Passer rating: 158.3

Passing yards: 348

Touchdown passes: 4

Despite the perfect passer rating, this one doesn't stand at the very top of the list due to contextual reasons. The 2020 Lions were not a good team and they lost six of their last seven while dealing with a long list of injuries and COVID-related absences. The Lions were even without some of their coaches in Week 17 against the visiting Buccaneers. This one was such a one-sided blowout that Brady only played one half before ceding the second half to Blaine Gabbert.

In a way, though, that makes this performance even more impressive. Brady's stat line of 22 completions in 27 attempts for 348 yards, four touchdowns and zero interceptions looks very much like a full game's worth of production. He likely would not have been throwing very much had he stayed in for the rest of the game. He led the Buccaneers' offense to touchdowns on five of the six drives he directed and repeatedly hit big plays downfield, including touchdowns of 33 yards to Rob Gronkowski and 27 yards to Mike Evans.

4. Craig Erickson, vs. Indianapolis, Sept. 11, 1994

Passer rating: 158.3

Passing yards: 313

Touchdown passes: 3

This is the first "perfect game" by a Buccaneers quarterback in franchise history, and it was just the 17th start of his NFL career. The Bucs were facing a Colts team that had trounced the Houston Oilers the week before, 45-21, to start their season (and one, coincidentally, that Erickson would be traded to the following year). That Erickson put together a 158.3 passer rating 26 years before any other Bucs quarterback could match it makes it deserving of inclusion on the list.

Both Erickson and Colts quarterback Jim Harbaugh completed exactly 19 of 24 passes in the game, but that turned into 313 yards and three scores for the Buccaneers' starter and just 206 and zero for Harbaugh. Erickson was also not intercepted or sacked in the game. He threw a 50-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Charles Wilson and a 48-yarder to tight end Jackie Harris and he went nine-of-10 for 167 yards and two scores in the second half as the Bucs protected a 10-3 halftime lead.

5. Ryan Fitzpatrick, at New Orleans, Sept. 9, 2018

Passer rating: 156.2

Passing yards: 417

Touchdown passes: 4

Fitzpatrick was at his gunslinger best in this one, a wild shootout that produced the most combined points ever in a season-opener. He completed 21 of 28 passes for 417 yards, four touchdowns and no interceptions and just missed out on a perfect passer rating by one completion. Had he finished 22 of 28, he would have joined Erickson, Brady and Mayfield in the perfection ranks, but his 417 yards is the most in any performance on this list.

Starting for a suspended Jameis Winston, Fitzpatrick was a big-play machine from the beginning in this one. His second pass of the game, on the Bucs' opening possession, was a 58-yard touchdown connection with DeSean Jackson. He later hit Jackson again on a 36-yard score and Evans on a 50-yard completion to the house. Though it doesn't factor into the passing-performance rankings, Fitzgerald also made key plays with his legs, first a three-yard touchdown run in the first quarter and then a 12-yard scramble on third-and-11 at the two-minute warning that ended the Saints' very scary fourth-quarter comeback attempt.

Related Content

Latest Headlines

2025 Home Games

Titans vs. Buccaneers

Preseason Week 1

August 9

7:30 PM ET

Bills vs. Buccaneers

Preseason Week 3

August 23

7:30 PM ET

Jets vs. Buccaneers

Week 3

September 21

1:00 PM ET

Eagles vs. Buccaneers

Week 4

September 28

1:00 PM ET

49ers vs. Buccaneers

Week 6

October 12

1:00 PM ET

Patriots vs. Buccaneers

Week 10

November 9

1:00 PM ET

Cardinals vs. Buccaneers

Week 13

November 30

1:00 PM ET

Saints vs. Buccaneers

Week 14

December 7

1:00 PM ET

Falcons vs. Buccaneers

Week 15

December 11

8:15 PM ET

Panthers vs. Buccaneers

Week 18

January 4

Time TBD

Advertising